Soft Material Butt Plugs

Shop our expertly curated selection of butt plugs made from soft materials. You'll find toys from brands like Oxballs, Portland Toy Company, Mood Naughty, and more.

Filters

$
to
$
99 products
Sort By:
Sort By:
Mood Naughty 1 Medium Silicone Butt Plug Mood Naughty 1 Medium Silicone Butt Plug
Mood Naughty 1 Medium Silicone Butt Plug
$27.00
Blush Luxe Be Me 3 Silicone Butt Plug Blush Luxe Be Me 3 Silicone Butt Plug
Blush Luxe Be Me 3 Silicone Butt Plug
From $21.00
b-Vibe Butties Lil Dil Silicone Penis Shaped Anal Plug With Ergonomic Finger Ring b-Vibe Butties Lil Dil Silicone Penis Shaped Anal Plug With Ergonomic Finger Ring
b-Vibe Butties Lil Dil Silicone Penis Shaped Anal Plug With Ergonomic Finger Ring
$32.00
Creature Cocks Dragon Hatch Silicone Fantasy Shaped Harnessable Egg Plug With Suction Cup #variant_id=48004716036329
Creature Cocks Dragon Hatch Silicone Fantasy Shaped Harnessable Egg Plug With Suction Cup
From $58.27
Nasstoys Tulip Finger Massager With Back And Forth Motion Rechargeable Rose Vibrator And Vibrating Pleasure Plug #variant_id=48004727472361
Nasstoys Tulip Finger Massager With Back And Forth Motion Rechargeable Rose Vibrator And Vibrating Pleasure Plug
$77.20
Sold out
Zero Tolerance Striker Remote-Controlled Rechargeable Vibrating Thrusting And Tapping Anal Vibe Zero Tolerance Striker Remote-Controlled Rechargeable Vibrating Thrusting And Tapping Anal Vibe
Zero Tolerance Striker Remote-Controlled Rechargeable Vibrating Thrusting And Tapping Anal Vibe
$112.00
Zero Tolerance Plug & Tug Silicone Rechargeable Vibrating Cock Ring & Combination Butt Plug Zero Tolerance Plug & Tug Silicone Rechargeable Vibrating Cock Ring & Combination Butt Plug
Zero Tolerance Plug & Tug Silicone Rechargeable Vibrating Cock Ring & Combination Butt Plug
$82.00
Nexus Shower Douche Duo Kit Silicone Curved Beginner Shower Douche
Nexus Shower Douche Duo Kit Silicone Curved Beginner Shower Douche
$70.00
Doc Johnson In A Bag 4 Inch Silicone Battery Operated Vibrating Butt Plug Doc Johnson In A Bag 4 Inch Silicone Battery Operated Vibrating Butt Plug
Doc Johnson In A Bag 4 Inch Silicone Battery Operated Vibrating Butt Plug
$23.00
Doc Johnson In A Bag 5 Inch Silicone Battery Operated Vibrating Butt Plug Doc Johnson In A Bag 5 Inch Silicone Battery Operated Vibrating Butt Plug
Doc Johnson In A Bag 5 Inch Silicone Battery Operated Vibrating Butt Plug
$25.00
Tantus Ringo Smooth Girthy Teardrop Shape Silicone Butt Plug #variant_id=48004583031017
Tantus Ringo Smooth Girthy Teardrop Shape Silicone Butt Plug
$63.00

DOC JOHNSON

Get 30% off our collection of Doc Johnson classic sex toys and kink gear thru October.

Use code: DOCTOBER

Shop Doc
Tantus Inner Band Trainer Advanced Anal Dilator Silicone Plug #variant_id=48004581425385
Tantus Inner Band Trainer Advanced Anal Dilator Silicone Plug
From $67.00
Oxballs Glowhole Hollow Tunnel Plug With LED Light Insert Oxballs Glowhole Hollow Tunnel Plug With LED Light Insert
Oxballs Glowhole Hollow Tunnel Gape Plug With LED Light Insert
From $76.00
Aneros MGX Syn Trident Prostate Massager Aneros MGX Syn Trident Prostate Massager
Aneros MGX Syn Trident Prostate Massager
$69.95
Aneros Eupho Syn Trident Prostate Massager Aneros Eupho Syn Trident Prostate Massager
Aneros Eupho Syn Trident Prostate Massager
$69.95
Sold out
Forto F-19 Curved Silicone Prostate Plug #variant_id=48004516708585
Forto F-19 Curved Silicone Prostate Plug
$24.00
Mood Naughty 1 Small Silicone Butt Plug Mood Naughty 1 Small Silicone Butt Plug
Mood Naughty 1 Small Silicone Butt Plug
$26.00
Mood Naughty 2 Large Silicone Butt Plug Mood Naughty 2 Large Silicone Butt Plug
Mood Naughty 2 Large Silicone Butt Plug
$29.00
Sold out
Mood Naughty 2 Medium Silicone Butt Plug Mood Naughty 2 Medium Silicone Butt Plug
Mood Naughty 2 Medium Silicone Butt Plug
$27.00
Tantus Little Flirt Slim Plug Tantus Little Flirt Slim Plug
Tantus Little Flirt Slim Plug
$32.00
b-Vibe Butties Thumb Curved Prostate Plug With Ergonomic Finger Ring b-Vibe Butties Thumb Curved Prostate Plug With Ergonomic Finger Ring
b-Vibe Butties Thumb Curved Prostate Plug With Ergonomic Finger Ring
$27.00
b-Vibe Butties Slide Sphere Shape Anal Plug With Ergonomic Finger Ring And Tapered Neck b-Vibe Butties Slide Sphere Shape Anal Plug With Ergonomic Finger Ring And Tapered Neck
b-Vibe Butties Slide Sphere Shape Anal Plug With Ergonomic Finger Ring And Tapered Neck
$27.00
b-Vibe Butties Pop Beaded Shape Anal Plug With Ergonomic Finger Ring b-Vibe Butties Pop Beaded Shape Anal Plug With Ergonomic Finger Ring
b-Vibe Butties Pop Beaded Shape Anal Plug With Ergonomic Finger Ring
$27.00
b-Vibe Butties Dart Rounded Tip Anal Plug With Ergonomic Finger Ring b-Vibe Butties Dart Rounded Tip Anal Plug With Ergonomic Finger Ring
b-Vibe Butties Dart Rounded Tip Anal Plug With Ergonomic Finger Ring
$27.00
#variant_id=49173646934249 #variant_id=49173646934249
XR Brand Master Series Dicked Clear Hollow Anal Gape Plug
From $22.00
#variant_id=49133727023337 #variant_id=49133727023337
VeDO Inme Flexible Powerful Curved Remote Control Vibrating Prostate Massager
$64.00
Nasstoys Goddess Diamond Rechargeable Vibrating Soft Silicone Plug Nasstoys Goddess Diamond Rechargeable Vibrating Soft Silicone Plug
Nasstoys Goddess Diamond Rechargeable Vibrating Soft Silicone Plug
$55.20
Sold out
Blush Oh My Gem Rechargeable Vibrating Mystery Plug Blush Oh My Gem Rechargeable Vibrating Mystery Plug
Blush Oh My Gem Rechargeable Vibrating Mystery Plug
$62.12
b-Vibe Butties Hither Silicone Finger Shaped Prostate Plug b-Vibe Butties Hither Silicone Finger Shaped Prostate Plug
b-Vibe Butties Hither Silicone Finger Shaped Prostate Plug
$27.00
b-Vibe Butties Bulb Shaped Silicone Prostate Plug b-Vibe Butties Bulb Shaped Silicone Prostate Plug
b-Vibe Butties Bulb Shaped Silicone Prostate Plug
$27.00
b-Vibe Butties Sleek Tapered Flexible Silicone Plug b-Vibe Butties Sleek Tapered Flexible Silicone Plug
b-Vibe Butties Sleek Tapered Flexible Silicone Plug
$27.00
Tantus Tex Silicone Extra Girthy Anal Plug #variant_id=48004681924841
Tantus Tex Silicone Extra Girthy Anal Plug
$74.00
Sold out
Tantus The DP Double Silicone Harnessable Bullet Compatible Dildo
Tantus The DP Double Silicone Harnessable Bullet Compatible Dildo
$102.00
JimmyJane Pulsus P-spot Rechargeable Come-Hither Motion Wearable Remote Control Dual Motor Vibrator JimmyJane Pulsus P-spot Rechargeable Come-Hither Motion Wearable Remote Control Dual Motor Vibrator
JimmyJane Pulsus P-spot Rechargeable Come-Hither Motion Wearable Remote Control Dual Motor Vibrator
$130.00
Nasstoys Atomic Inflatable Prostate Remote-Control Rechargeable Silicone Butt Plug Vibrator Nasstoys Atomic Inflatable Prostate Remote-Control Rechargeable Silicone Butt Plug Vibrator
Nasstoys Atomic Inflatable Prostate Remote-Control Rechargeable Silicone Butt Plug Vibrator
$73.50
Sold out
Gender X Anybody's Plug Rechargeable Curved Silicone Plug Gender X Anybody's Plug Rechargeable Curved Silicone Plug
Gender X Anybody's Plug Rechargeable Curved Silicone Plug
$60.00
Nasstoys Silicone H2O Hydro Douche 3-in-1 Shower Kit Nasstoys Silicone H2O Hydro Douche 3-in-1 Shower Kit
Nasstoys Silicone H2O Hydro Douche 3-in-1 Shower Kit
$82.70
Sold out
Nexus Shower Douche Duo Kit Silicone Rippled Advanced Shower Douche
Nexus Shower Douche Duo Kit Silicone Rippled Advanced Shower Douche
$72.00
Nu Sensuelle 15 Function Rechargeable Silicone Mini Plug With Vibrating Remote Control Nu Sensuelle 15 Function Rechargeable Silicone Mini Plug With Vibrating Remote Control
Nu Sensuelle 15 Function Rechargeable Silicone Mini Plug With Vibrating Remote Control
$88.99