Soft Material Butt Plugs

Shop our expertly curated selection of butt plugs made from soft materials. You'll find toys from brands like Oxballs, Portland Toy Company, Mood Naughty, and more.

Filters

$
to
$
95 products
Sort By:
Sort By:
Mood Naughty 1 Anal Trainer Set Mood Naughty 1 Anal Trainer Set
Mood Naughty 1 Anal Trainer Set
$37.00
Biird Regii 2-Piece Anal Plug Set Biird Regii 2-Piece Anal Plug Set
Biird Regii 2-Piece Anal Plug Set
$22.00
Mood Naughty Pride Rainbow Anal Training Set
Mood Naughty Pride Rainbow Anal Training Set
$39.00
Creature Cocks Xeno Egg Fantasy Shaped Girthy Glow-in-the-Dark Silicone Egg With Strong Suction Cup #variant_id=48004689199337
Creature Cocks Xeno Egg Fantasy Shaped Girthy Glow-in-the-Dark Silicone Egg With Strong Suction Cup
From $58.32
Blush Anal Adventures Matrix Voyager Rechargeable Vibrating Ergonomic Plug Blush Anal Adventures Matrix Voyager Rechargeable Vibrating Ergonomic Plug
Blush Anal Adventures Matrix Voyager Rechargeable Vibrating Ergonomic Plug
$41.38
Colors Pleasures Mini Beginner Silicone Butt Plug #variant_id=48004515070185
Colors Pleasures Mini Beginner Silicone Butt Plug
$14.40
Shots Fist It Silicone Textured Stretchy Stimulation Glove Shots Fist It Silicone Textured Stretchy Stimulation Glove
Shots Fist It Silicone Textured Stretchy Stimulation Glove
$45.95
Blush Play with Me Naughty Candy Heart Silicone Butt Plug Blush Play with Me Naughty Candy Heart Silicone Butt Plug
Blush Play with Me Naughty Candy Heart Silicone Butt Plug
From $19.34
Tantus Cone Anal Dilator Trainer Silicone Plug #variant_id=48004595876073
Tantus Cone Anal Dilator Trainer Silicone Plug
From $47.00
B-Vibe Classic Black Silicone Enema B-Vibe Classic Black Silicone Enema
B-Vibe Classic Black Silicone Enema
$22.50
Save $0.04
Master Series Ass Bung Clear Hollow Anal Gape Plug Master Series Ass Bung Clear Hollow Anal Gape Plug
Master Series Ass Bung Clear Hollow Anal Gape Plug
$25.96 $26.00

Blush Sale!

Shop our Blush Novelties sale and get 30% off some of our most popular sex toys across categories! Use code: BlushLove

Shop Blush
Rocks-Off Petite Sensations Teazer Silicone Butt Plug Rocks-Off Petite Sensations Teazer Silicone Butt Plug
Rocks-Off Petite Sensations Teazer Silicone Butt Plug
$27.00
Tantus Severin Tiered Anal Plug With Long Neck For Comfort #variant_id=48004677435625
Tantus Severin Tiered Anal Plug With Long Neck For Comfort
From $36.00
Oxballs Pighole Hollow Silicone Tunnel Plug #variant_id=48004573266153
Oxballs Pighole Hollow Silicone Tunnel Gape Plug
From $79.00
#variant_id=48004566941929
Evolved Luminous Glow-in-the-Dark Core Silicone Butt Plug
$19.99